The First Brief

How a lawyer actually learns law — the apprenticeship, written down.

There are excellent books on the Code of Civil Procedure. There are excellent commentaries on the Specific Relief Act. There are form books thick enough to prop open a door. And not one of them tells you what to do on Tuesday morning.

They answer the question what is the law. They never answer the question what do I do now — which is the only question a new advocate actually has, standing in a chamber with a client on one side of the table and a blank page on the other.

That gap is not an accident. The answer has always been passed down by apprenticeship: you watch your senior, you carry files, you are corrected in the corridor, and after two or three years the shape of the work finally appears to you. It works. It is also slow, uneven, and entirely dependent on the luck of whose chamber you happened to walk into.

This series is an attempt to write that apprenticeship down.

Who it is for

The junior in his or her first two years, who can recite Order VII Rule 1 and has never seen a plaint accepted at a counter. The law student who wants to know what the job is before choosing it. The litigant who would like to understand what his advocate is doing, and why it is taking so long. And the senior who is tired of explaining the same thing to a new junior every year, and would like something to hand over instead.

How to read it

Thirty lectures, in the order in which the work actually happens — from the first question a client is asked to the last order a court passes. Each one takes a single stage of a civil case and stays with it: the reasoning first, in plain language, with the provisions arriving at the moment they become useful rather than as a list to be memorised in advance. Every lecture ends with one thing to do — draft it, find it, or read it backwards — before you turn to the next.

Reading without doing those exercises will leave you well informed and no more useful than you were. Doing them is the course.

A necessary warning about State law

India has one Code of Civil Procedure and one Specific Relief Act. It does not have one court-fee law, one rent law, or one set of court forms. Court fee is largely State legislation. Tenancy is State legislation. Forms, requisites and counter practice are local — sometimes local to a single court building.

So wherever these lectures give a figure, a form name or a counter procedure, treat it as an illustration of the pattern and not as authority for your own filing. Take the figure from the Act in force where you file, and from the fee chart in your own filing section. The reasoning transfers everywhere. The numbers do not.

Nothing here is legal advice, and nothing here is a substitute for reading the current statute, its amendments, the High Court rules and the law of limitation as they stand on the day you file.

The rule the whole series rests on

Facts create a right. Somebody invades the right. The invasion entitles you to a relief.

The relief has a section number. The section number decides the valuation, the court fee, the forum and the prayer. And every paragraph you write in the plaint exists to earn one of those prayers.

Nothing in a plaint is decorative. If a paragraph is not earning a prayer, delete it.

Continue the series

NextS1 L1 — Why Do We Need Law at All?

All thirty lecturesThe First Brief — full contents

Chanda AssociatesHome · Law Updates · About Us · Advocates · Contact